Billy Taggart was the son of Jack Taggart Sr. and younger brother of Jack Jr. While setting up scarecrows throughout the field, Billy notices one of the Scarecrows suddenly move its head. Billy backs away in fear and begins running throughout the field. The Creeper leaps into the air and wrestles Billy to the ground. Jack Sr. and Jack Jr. suddenly hear cries for help and notice a dark figure running through the field. Weilding a shotgun Jack pursues The Creeper but to no avail. The Creeper takes off in the air with young Billy in his possession. Billy is shown again in a dream sequence along with Darry Jenner trying to warn Minxie Hayes who is among the students on the school bus of The Creeper's presence. Meanwhile, Billy's father and brother were putting together a large homemade harpoon to attack the Creeper for murdering Billy.
- It's not known what the Creeper took from Billy, but his head wound in the dream suggests it was a part of his brain. Billy was taken to the Creeper's new lair and was probably hung on the wall like all the other corpses along with Darry Jenner from the first movie.